Venu Srinivasan Raises Concerns Against Noel Tata, Alleges Irregularities in Tata Trusts…

A fresh dispute has erupted within the Tata Trusts, as trustee Venu Srinivasan has approached the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner protesting against the management and administration practices of the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT) and Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT). In his complaint, Srinivasan has alleged ‘serious governance lapses’ and questioned ‘the involvement of the charitable trusts and its trustees in the commercial and strategic affairs of Tata Sons’. In his complaint, Srinivasan has questioned the appointment and retention of Noel Tata as a perpetual trustee. He has questioned the basis for the appointment of Noel Tata as the chair of the Tata Trusts, and the manner in which his son Neville was appointed as a trustee. Srinivasan has also alleged that he was deliberately excluded from key decision-making processes. In this regard, he has sought directions restricting the voting powers of Noel Tata on certain Tata Sons-related matters, and has sought status quo on the composition of the board of SDTT, while the matter is pending before the Charity Commissioner. A pertinent issue pertains to the role of various Tata Trusts in Tata Sons, which collectively holds about 66% of the equity in the company. In this regard, Srinivasan has cited the Trusts’ own September 17 statement on exploring alternatives to a listing of shares of Tata Sons, as well as discussions concerning liquidity for the Shapoorji Pallonji Group as evidence that the Trusts had strayed into directly managing certain key commercial issues pertaining to Tata Sons. Srinivasan has argued that such intervention could be detrimental to the charitable objectives of the Trusts, and questioned their tax-exempt status. The latest complaint comes as part of a larger governance row surrounding Tata Sons and the Trusts. In this regard, Business Standard reported that the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner’s office has been probing developments surrounding the Trusts and their dealings with Tata Sons. Meanwhile, Financial Express reported that the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust is considering filing a caveat before the Charity Commissioner in response to Srinivasan’s protest, which has alleged irregularities in appointments of trustees, and governance lapses, which could be subject to scrutiny by the Charity Commissioner.